Zoom chat: 2023-02-22 ​​At-Large Consolidated Policy Working Group (CPWG)

00:30:30    Jonathan Zuck: Good question, @JM. Presumably, there would be some contractual prohibition from converting, no?
00:30:41    Yeşim Saglam - ICANN Org: RTT Link: https://www.streamtext.net/player?event=ICANN
00:31:18    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: Was thinking about how unused brand gTLDs from 2012 were sold off JZ. It could be an easy way to game the system.
00:31:48    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: @JZ It might need some clauses in the contract.
00:32:37    Jonathan Zuck: I might speak up during AOB
00:32:56    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: Thanks.
00:33:15    Alfredo Calderon: Replying to "On the private use T..."

I would assume that additionally a process to request new designation must be in place where a “cool off period and the actual contractual agreement must have clause on this.
00:33:24    Mouloud Khelif: Apologies for my late arrival
00:34:46    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: @Alfredo It might need the lawyers to sort it out because if it isn't mentioned in the contract then it would be harder to decline a request.
00:37:43    Alfredo Calderon: @John, agreed on the legal input needed.
00:41:06    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: Will three letter country codes be specifically excluded?
00:42:48    Jonathan Zuck: very
00:44:00    Mouloud Khelif: Thanks for the question, and for the explanation, very clear now
00:44:48    Jonathan Zuck: to prevent name collisions
00:48:29    Christopher Wilkinson: Will private TLDs extend to IDNs? - CW
00:50:56    Mouloud Khelif: Yes
00:51:07    Jonathan Zuck: do we even have a position?
00:51:33    Jonathan Zuck: our cautions seem "obvious" at this point
00:51:39    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: A hypothetical position for a hypothetical question?
00:52:16    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: We need to keep our options open.
00:52:16    Olivier MJ Crepin-Leblond: Consensus call ok
00:52:21    Christopher Wilkinson: I wold likd to see the poV of the CJK group
00:52:34    Roberto Gaetano: no objection
00:54:22    Jonathan Zuck: they leak NOW. Ideally, this would at least lesson the frequency of such leaks
00:55:03    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: They leak but are not routed as the DNSes generally give an NXDOMAIN error.
00:56:01    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: Now when someone uses a real TLD or domain name on their local net and it exists on the Internet, problems can and do happen.
00:56:22    Hadia El Miniawi (ALAC-Member): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y6F2WO0bO1r03pyGSH4xNm19DVYaMjvX1ZDZ9IsFkv8/edit
01:12:48    Seb Bachollet: Can we used the slot cancel by OFB for that purpose ?
01:19:18    Amrita Choudhury: Its a good idea JZ if some material is shared beforehand so that we get a better understanding and start thinking.
01:19:34    Alfredo Calderon: Reacted to "Its a good idea JZ i..." with
01:19:39    Amrita Choudhury: Reacted to "Its a good idea JZ i..." with
01:21:06    Raymond Mamattah: +1 for Amrita
01:21:47    Hadia El Miniawi (ALAC-Member): +1 lets reopen the discussion
01:23:21    Jonathan Zuck: Definitely
01:23:33    Christopher Wilkinson: @ Olivier, +1.  Avri has left the call.
01:24:47    Jonathan Zuck: I think she's still here CW
01:25:03    avri doria: I think so too
01:25:19    Jonathan Zuck: Our favorite lurker!
01:28:48    Amrita Choudhury: lol Avri , but thank you
01:30:19    Chokri Ben Romdhane: Web 3.0 technologies and its impact is also a good way to better serve  end users!
01:30:30    Chokri Ben Romdhane: hope you have a fast recovery @Jonathan
01:32:27    Amrita Choudhury: Yay! We are happy from my part of the world :)
01:33:04    Chantelle Doerksen - ICANN Org: Thank you everyone for joining!
01:33:08    Herb Waye Ombuds: See you all in a few weeks. Stay safe and be kind.
01:33:09    John McCormac - HosterStats.com: Thanks and later all.
01:33:13    Olivier KOUAMI: Thank you
01:33:14    Bram Fudzulani: Thanks and bye
01:33:16    Chokri Ben Romdhane: Thank you Olivier and all
01:33:24    Alfredo Calderon: Have a great day, afternoon, evening.
01:33:28    Mouloud Khelif: Thanks everyone
01:33:28    Laura Margolis: Byee
01:33:29    Hadia El Miniawi (ALAC-Member): Thank you all
01:33:31    Hadia El Miniawi (ALAC-Member): bye
01:33:33    Sivasubramanian M: Thank you !
01:33:33    Roberto Gaetano: bye all
01:33:38    Priyatosh Jana: Bye