Public Comment Review Tool
- Marika Konings
- Berry Cobb
- Terri Agnew
- Caitlin Tubergen
To facilitate the EPDP Team's review of the public comments received, the staff support team has developed the following public comment review tool for each section / question / recommendation:
Under Development
| Section | Most Recent Version | History |
|---|---|---|
| XLS Export of Data | 8 Jan - EPDP On the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data - Public Comment Proceeding Input Form (Responses).xlsx | |
| Purpose 1 - Establish the rights of a Registered Name Holder | 02 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190102.docx gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190102.pdf (corrected inadvertent replacement of 'agreement' by 'support' in three of the comments) 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181228.docx (removed template data for un-closed entries) 25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) 23 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181223.docx | |
| Purpose 2 - Maintaining SSR through enabling of lawful access | 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose2_12262018.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Purpose 3 - Enable communication with RNH | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20181228.docx (reviewed by sub-team B, proposed final language) 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Purpose 4 - Safeguarding RNH's Registration Data | 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE4_20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Purpose 5 - Handling Contractual Compliance | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_5 20181228.docx | 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_5 20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
| Purpose 6 - Resolution of DRPs | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_6 20181228.docx | 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_6 20181228.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
| Purpose 7 - gTLD registration policy eligibility criteria | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_7 20181228.docx | 26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_7 20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
Recommendation #1 Additional Comments + Question 1 - Additional Purposes | 3 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_1 additional comments and purposes.docx gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_1 additional comments and purposes.pdf | |
| Recommendation #2 - Commitment to consider a system for Standardized Access to non-public Registration Data | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC2_20181228.docx | 25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec2_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
| Recommendation #3 - Requirements related to accuracy | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC3_20181228.docx | 25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC3_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
| Recommendation #4 - Data elements to be collected by Registrars (incl. Question #2) | 04 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC4_20190104.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC4_20181228.docx (Correction to submission) |
| Recommendation #5 - Data elements to be transferred from Registrars to Registries | 30 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC5_20181230.docx | |
| Recommendation #6 - Escrow Providers | 30 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC6_20181230.docx | |
| Recommendation #7 - Contractual Compliance | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC7_20181231.docx | |
| Recommendation #8 - Redaction | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC8_20181231.docx | |
| Recommendation #9 - Organization field | 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_9_20181227.docx | |
| Recommendation #10 - Email communication | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC10_20181231.docx | 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_10_20181227.docx (update to graph) |
| Recommendation #11 - Data retention | ||
| Question #3 - Geo / Legal vs. Natural | 3 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.docx gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.pdf | 03 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.docx (Correction to submission) |
| Recommendation #12 - Reasonable access | 18 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20190118.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20191228.docx (omitted GAC comment 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20191227.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) |
| Recommendation #13 - Controller Agreement | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC13_20181231.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC13_20181228.docx (update to graph) |
| Recommendation #14 - Responsible parties | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_14_20181231.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_14_20181228.docx (update to graph) |
| Recommendation #15 - URS / UDRP | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_15_20182831.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_15_20182812.docx (update to graph) |
| Recommendation #16 - Instructions for RPM PDP WG | 31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_16_20181231.docx | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_16_20181228.docx (update to graph) |
| Recommendation #17 - Input from RPM PDP WG to inform subsequent access discussion | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181228.docx (update to graph) 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181227.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Recommendation #18 - Data processing agreements with dispute resolution providers (incl. Question #4) | 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC18_20181227.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Recommendation #19 - Transfer Policy | 28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20181228.docx (reviewed by sub-team B, no changes) 27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20181227.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts) | |
| Recommendation #20 - Input to Transfer Policy review (incl. Question #5) | ||
| Recommendation #21 - Data processing agreements with non-Contracted Party entities involved in registration data processing | ||
| Recommendation #22 - Impact on other policies | 29 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC22_20181228.docx (update to graph) | |
| General Comments | 2 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-General_Comments_20190102.docx |