Public Comment Review Tool

Public Comment Review Tool

To facilitate the EPDP Team's review of the public comments received, the staff support team has developed the following public comment review tool for each section / question / recommendation:



Under Development

Section

Most Recent Version

History

Section

Most Recent Version

History

XLS Export of Data

8 Jan - EPDP On the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data - Public Comment Proceeding Input Form (Responses).xlsx



Purpose 1 -

Establish the rights of a Registered Name Holder 

8 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190108.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190108.pdf

PURPOSE 1 - discussion table.docx



02 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190102.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20190102.pdf

(corrected inadvertent replacement of 'agreement' by 'support' in three of the comments)

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181228.docx (removed template data for un-closed entries)

25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

23 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE1_20181223.docx

Purpose 2 - Maintaining SSR through enabling of lawful access

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose2_12282018.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose2_12282018.pdf

PURPOSE 2 - discussion table.docx

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose2_12262018.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Purpose 3 - Enable communication with RNH

8 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20190108.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20190108.pdf

PURPOSE 3 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20181228.docx (reviewed by sub-team B, proposed final language)

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE3_20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Purpose 4 - Safeguarding RNH's Registration Data 

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE4_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE4_20181228.pdf

PURPOSE 4 - discussion table.docx

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-PURPOSE4_20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Purpose 5 - Handling Contractual Compliance

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_5 20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_5 20181228.pdf

PURPOSE 5 - discussion table.docx

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_5 20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Purpose 6 - Resolution of DRPs

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_6 20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_6 20181228.pdf

PURPOSE 6 - discussion table.docx

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_6 20181228.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Purpose 7 - gTLD registration policy eligibility criteria 

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_7 20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_7 20181228.pdf

PURPOSE 7 - discussion table.docx

26 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Purpose_7 20181226.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #1 Additional Comments +

Question 1 - Additional Purposes

3 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_1 additional comments and purposes.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_1 additional comments and purposes.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 1 - Discussion Table.docx



Recommendation #2 -

Commitment to consider a system for Standardized Access to non-public Registration Data

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC2_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC2_20181228.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 2 - concerns table.docx

25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec2_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

23 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec2_20181223.docx

Recommendation #3 - Requirements related to accuracy

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC3_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC3_20181228.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 3 - Concerns Table.docx

25 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC3_20181225.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #4 - Data elements to be collected by Registrars (incl. Question #2)

04 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC4_20190104.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC4_20190104.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 4 - concerns table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC4_20181228.docx (Correction to submission)

Recommendation #5 - Data elements to be transferred from Registrars to Registries

30 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC5_20181230.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC5_20181230.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 5 - concerns table.docx



Recommendation #6 - Escrow Providers

30 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC6_20181230.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC6_20181230.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 6 - discussion table - upd.docx



Recommendation #7 - Contractual Compliance

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC7_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC7_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 7 - concerns table.docx



Recommendation #8 - Redaction

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC8_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC8_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 8 - concerns table.docx



Recommendation #9 - Organization field

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_9_20181227.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_9_20181227.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 9 concerns table.docx



Recommendation #10 - Email communication

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC10_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC10_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 10 - discussion table.docx

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_10_20181227.docx (update to graph)

Recommendation #11 - Data retention

30 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC11_20181230.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC11_20181230.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 11 - discussion table - upd.docx





Question #3 - Geo / Legal vs. Natural

3 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.pdf



03 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-QUESTION3_20190103.docx (Correction to submission)

Recommendation #12 - Reasonable access

18 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20190118.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20190118.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 12 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20191228.docx (omitted GAC comment

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_12_20191227.docx (contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #13 - Controller Agreement

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC13_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC13_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 13 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC13_20181228.docx (update to graph)

Recommendation #14 - Responsible parties

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_14_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_14_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 14 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-Rec_14_20181228.docx (update to graph)

Recommendation #15 - URS / UDRP

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_15_20182831.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_15_20182831.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 15 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_15_20182812.docx (update to graph)

Recommendation #16 - Instructions for RPM PDP WG

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_16_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_16_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 16 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC_16_20181228.docx (update to graph)

Recommendation #17 - Input from RPM PDP WG to inform subsequent access discussion

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 17 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181228.docx (update to graph)

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC17_20181227.docx

(contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #18 - Data processing agreements with dispute resolution providers (incl. Question #4)

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC18_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC18_20181228.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 18 - discussion table.docx

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC18_20181227.docx

(contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #19 - Transfer Policy

8 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20190108.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20190108.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 19 - discussion table.docx

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20181228.docx (reviewed by sub-team B, no changes)

27 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC19_20181227.docx

(contained duplicate entries for Theo Geurts)

Recommendation #20 - Input to Transfer Policy review (incl. Question #5)

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC20_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC20_20181228.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 20 - discussion table.docx



Recommendation #21 - Data processing agreements with non-Contracted Party entities involved in registration data processing

28 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC21_20181228.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC21_20181228.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 21 - discussion table.docx



Recommendation #22 - Impact on other policies

31 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC22_20181231.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC22_20181231.pdf

RECOMMENDATION 22 - discussion table.docx

29 Dec - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-REC22_20181228.docx (update to graph)

General Comments

2 Jan - gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-General_Comments_20190102.docx

gnso-EPDP-pcrt-Initial-Report-General_Comments_20190102.pdf

General Comments - discussion table.docx