2017-05-17 Next Gen RDS PDP Working Group

The next GNSO Next-Gen RDS PDP Working Group teleconference will take place on Wednesday, 17 May at 05:00 UTC for 90 minutes. 

22:00 PDT (Tuesday), 01:00 EDT, 06:00 London, 07:00 CET 

For other times:

PROPOSED AGENDA: 

1) Roll Call/SOI Updates

2) Brief updates

a) Newcomer tutorial plans:

• Tuesday 23 May, immediately following WG Call
• Recording available for on-demand replay

b) ICANN59 meeting plans:

• Monday 26 June Cross-Community Session on RDS
• Tuesday 27 June Face-to-Face RDS PDP WG Session

3) Review proposed-final definition(s) to replace "authoritative" in Statement of Purpose, Item 2):

• Data of Record Proposal to be presented by David Cake on behalf of small team

4) Continue deliberation on the charter question 5: What steps should be taken to control "thin data" access?

a) Is "thin data" access authentication required or allowed?

• • Proposed answer: Based on Poll Question 2) Option e)
  • "Thin data elements must be accessible without requestor authentication."
  • See SummaryResults-Poll-from-9MayCall.pdf and Charter Question 5 - Handout - For17MayCall.pdf 

b) Is "thin data" access anonymity required or allowed?

• • Proposed answer: Based on Poll Question 2) Comment 9:
  • "Access to thin registration data must be provided to anonymous requestors."

c) Define "anonymous" and "authentication"

d) Should policies allow or prevent application of operational controls?

• • Rough consensus WG Agreement (75%) on Poll Question 3):
  • There must be no RDS policies that prevent RDS operators from applying operational controls such as rate limiting and CAPTCHA, provided that they do not unreasonably restrict legitimate access."
  •  Need to define specific policy for "reasonable" and "legitimate" during Phase 2 of this PDP?

e) Review all of charter question 5 sub-questions with goal to complete first pass deliberation on "thin data" access in May

5) Confirm action items and proposed decision points

6) Confirm next meeting date: 23 May 2017 at 16:00 UTC